Please find below the 200+ Game players for the Carey Park FC.
| Name | Games |
| Shaun O’Callaghan | 370 |
| Arron Hill | 301 |
| John Panizza | 267 |
| Graeme Carlson | 264 |
| Neville Hoskins | 264 |
| Errol Barrett | 241 |
| Sean Widdeson | 228 |
| Neil Lloyd | 225 |
| Richard Barnard | 220 |
| Shane Jones | 211 |
| Viv Blurton | 210 |
| Liam Stewart | 209 |
| Ben Neale (78 BSN/131 CP) | 209 |
| Stan Willis (Jnr) | 203 |
| Jy King | 201 |
| Murray Collard | 201 |
| Shannon Spadaccini | 201 |
| Lawrie Bennett (+HB/BY) | 148 |
Please note: This list is updated at the conclusion of each football season.